Blogs

The Trade Desk

Programmatic

Blogs

The Trade Desk

The Open Internet Needs Indies. Here's How They Win.

Matt Fogarty

By Matt Fogarty, SVP of Sales, Mogl

We opened our NYC office earlier this year. To officially plant the flag this October, we teamed up with our longtime partner The Trade Desk and brought a room full of independent agency leaders to their 46th floor office. I was joined on stage by Ben Jurist, Co-Founder of Grain Group, and Gillian Gold, Senior Director at The Trade Desk.

The question we wanted to answer: what does it take for an independent agency to win on the open internet right now? It is a critical question and it matters more now than ever. 

‍

The Open Internet's Missing Middle

At Mogl, we are very prescriptive in our market - the “M” of the SMB. These brands generate  $10- $100m in revenue and spend between $500k-$5m in total advertising spend.  There are over half a million of them in the US alone and represent 35% of all U.S. ad spend. In doing so, most work with one of the 10,000+ independent agencies across the country.¹

However, the open internet has largely failed them. Consumers spend most of their digital time on CTV, podcasts, streaming and premium publishers. But most mid-market budgets still land in walled gardens, search, and social.  

There are 4 key reasons why the Open Internet has underperformed for independent agencies to date:

  1. First Party Data: Activating 1p Data has proven expensive, with high barriers to entry for mid-market brands to leverage the tools necessary to unlock the value from their 1p data assets.  With Google, Meta, Amazon, etc, a brand can access a scaled, high fidelity 1p data set.  It turns out, that performs well. 
  2. Direct Supply Chain:  Last year, Sincera & The Trade Desk released a report that showed approximately 600 supply paths for every impression.  Together with intermediaries driving up the costs of media on the open internet, mid-market brands have difficulty enabling enough of their advertising spend to go towards working media at the requisite efficiency.  Walled Gardens provide direct access to their owned & operated media, which together with a 1p data assets, performs well. 
  3. Measurement: You can debate the efficacy of their models - and we will - but the reality is that most buyers believe when they put $10 into those ecosystems, they get $15 out. The open internet has to date not been able to deliver the trusted, data-driven measurement to justify more meaningful ad dollars. 
  4. Usability: Meta, Google, Amazon has easy to use interfaces designed even for the “S” of the SMB and the enterprise platforms for the open internet require a dedicated service layer to unlock the value and performance from those technologies. 

These barriers represent a fundamental threat to publishers and the open internet more broadly. Brands miss audiences where they actually spend time. Publishers miss a huge share of the dollars that keep great content and journalism funded. The open internet can't run on the Fortune 500 alone, as publishers will need a scalable, thriving mid to long tail of demand to fund reinvestment into the premium content we all know, love, and depend on. 

That’s the mission for Mogl - to empower independent agencies and growth brands to unlock the value from the open internet to drive better business outcomes. 

‍

What We Heard On Stage

Three themes kept coming up.

1. The supply chain is too long. There can be hundreds of paths to a single impression, and every extra hop takes a cut. Mid-market buyers usually don't have the tools to cut through it. Shorter, direct paths from publisher to SSP to DSP mean more of a client's budget goes to media that actually performs.

2. Silos slow agencies down. When account teams and execution teams work separately, things get lost between them. Ben walked through how Grain Group is rebuilding around that:

  • Generalist traders who can buy across programmatic, search, social and retail media
  • One source of truth that connects media metrics to client outcomes in Shopify, Amazon, HubSpot and Salesforce
  • Impact planning that runs custom MMM up front, so clients see forecasted outcomes before they commit budget

3. AI should raise the bar for people, not replace them. As platforms automate the routine work, an agency's value moves to strategy and judgment. The panel agreed AI can turn a full day of data wrangling into a couple of hours, freeing traders to act as real consultants. They also agreed agencies shouldn't cut junior roles to get there. Those people are tomorrow's leaders.

The group shared a simple path for adopting AI:

  1. Let your team build small tools that fix their daily headaches
  2. Stand up internal task forces for automated audits and reporting
  3. Move to agents that plan campaigns proactively

‍

Where Mogl Fits

Everything we heard that night is why Mogl exists. We're not here to add another layer between agencies and the open internet. We're here to get indies in and help them win once they're there.

As a Certified Service Partner of The Trade Desk, here's what we bring:

  • Unlocking the open internet. Indies get the same enterprise-grade programmatic the big holding companies use, across CTV, audio, retail media and premium publishers.
  • Clean supply paths. We help agencies cut the extra hops, so more of every dollar reaches the publishers and audiences that matter.
  • Data that proves outcomes. Bringing 1p data assets to bear - for free - and connecting media to the business results clients care about, beyond what platform dashboards report.
  • A real team behind you. Strategy, stack builds and hands-on support come with the partnership to unleash the power of enterprise-grade tools.
  • AI built for traders. Mogl Labs builds tools that take the busywork off a team's plate, so they spend more time on strategy.

We don't do silos. We build systems that make indies faster, sharper and easier to trust.

‍

Built for what's next

The independent agency of the future isn't grinding through manual tasks in a silo. It's buying across the open internet with clean paths, connected data and AI that makes its people better. It's accountable for real results.

That's the agency we're building Mogl for, and New York is a big part of that next chapter. Thank you to The Trade Desk, Ben, Gillian and everyone who joined us. Let's keep the conversation going.

Connect with the Mogl team

‍

Sources:
  1. eMarketer 2025; Kantar 2025; MJF Advisory Mid-Market Analysis

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the open internet in programmatic advertising?
The open internet refers to digital ad inventory outside walled gardens like Google, Meta, and Amazon. It includes connected TV (CTV), digital audio, premium news publishers, and independent websites where consumers spend a significant portion of their digital time.

Why do mid-market brands struggle on the open internet?
Mid-market brands face four main barriers on the open internet: high costs for activating first-party data, complex and inefficient supply chains, a lack of transparent cross-channel measurement, and complex enterprise DSP interfaces that require dedicated service layers.

How can independent agencies streamline their programmatic supply chain?
Independent agencies can reduce supply path complexity by establishing direct connections between publishers, SSPs, and DSPs. Cutting unnecessary intermediaries ensures a larger portion of advertising budgets goes toward working media rather than platform fees.

How can independent agencies leverage enterprise DSPs like The Trade Desk?
Independent agencies can access enterprise-grade platforms like The Trade Desk by partnering with Certified Service Partners like Mogl. This approach provides access to premium inventory, advanced targeting, and transparent pricing without requiring massive spend commitments or dedicated internal DSP trading desks.

What role does AI play for modern independent media agencies?
AI enables independent agencies to automate routine data wrangling, automated audits, and campaign reporting. This shifts the agency's primary role from execution to strategy and judgment, allowing trading teams to deliver higher-value consulting to clients.

Get this resource 
in your inbox

Enter your name and email address to 
access this resource.

Please use your business email so we can connect you with the right team.
Join our mailing list to get this content & more.
By submitting, you agree to our Privacy Policy. 
Thanks for submitting the form.